Car Discuss

Expensive Automobile Converse: Need to I repair service or swap my 2004 BMW 325xi with significantly less than 24,000 miles on it? It’s crimson and the body and exterior are in excellent issue. But the pursuing repairs have been proposed:

◼️ Exchange the energy steering reservoir, which is leaking, and flush the process.

◼️ Correct leak in rear differential address.

◼️ Exchange rear brakes (3mm, rotors, sensors).

◼️ Switch primary tires.

◼️ 4 wheel alignment.

The approximated cost is $7,000. Really should I provide it or do the repairs? I am 75, and I did not get an additional estimate.


Pricey PD: The first detail you must do is drop the address of this restore shop. That appears, to me, like an outrageous volume of income for that work. I’ll give you an notion of what it would price tag in our store.

Changing the electricity steering reservoir and flushing it out need to value a handful of hundred pounds. Replacing the differential seal really should cost no much more than $150. For a 4-wheel alignment, let us say yet another $150. The rear brakes, becoming generous, let’s say $700.

And for tires, even if you used $250 per tire, which is what you would fork out for best of the line general performance tires, that is $1,000. So let’s see. I get $2,300. Even if you went to the vendor, exactly where they demand a high quality, that restore purchase shouldn’t price a lot more than about $3,500.

So unless of course you remaining a thing out of your letter, the guys you went to are charging you at minimum double. That places them in Nigerian Electronic mail Scam terrain. So the response is, if you like the car or truck, PD, and it continue to serves your wants, you should really preserve the auto, and trade in your mechanic.

If you require help obtaining a far better mechanic, go to That is the place our readers and listeners have shared the names of mechanics they like and believe in. You can research by ZIP code and read the opinions. And then go get a further estimate or two. I believe that’ll make you really feel a ton improved, whatsoever you make a decision.

Pricey Automobile Discuss: I have a 2003 Honda Component EX. I enjoy the motor vehicle. It is the greatest auto I’ve ever owned (and I have owned 17 cars overall). My spouse available to purchase me a new 2011 Factor when I turned 40. At the time, I advised her my 2003 Component was fantastic. The interior has canine hair in the cracks, the sprint is scratched from masses of lumber and pipes, it was the car or truck we took on our initially date — and it was paid out for in whole.

Honda stopped producing the Factor in 2011, and I now regret declining the supply. My 2003 Ingredient has 197,000 miles on it. It operates perfectly but burns and leaks oil, and the transmission is slipping. And in 3,000 miles I am owing for a key company. That services and some now essential repairs will charge me about $4,000.

Or I could invest in a 2008 Honda Ingredient EX with only 37,000 miles that has some entrance-finish destruction for about $3,000. I think I can correct the 2008 for about $3,500. Really should I hold and take care of my trustworthy and beloved 2003 Factor with all the difficulties I know nicely, or acquire the youthful, decrease miles Element and promote my current 1, which is worthy of about $3,500 as is? Many thanks.


Dear Bill: Cars are not spouses. They never adore you again. Nor do they hold your dwelling. So when it arrives to automobiles, we thoroughly endorse investing for a younger model. Specially in your situation. Regardless of our passionate notions, cars and trucks will not get greater with age. They have on out.

They have a useful everyday living. And for a although, you can change areas and retain them serviceable. But at some position, they start slipping apart a lot quicker than you can put them back jointly. And at that issue, the expense will become prohibitive, even if the inconvenience does not.

And the very best measure of helpful lifestyle? Mileage. It truly is not excellent, due to the fact some people beat up their vehicles with stop and go website traffic and potholes, and some persons infant their vehicles on smooth highways. But typically talking, a car or truck with reduced mileage will have extra handy existence than a car with better mileage.

And in your circumstance, it truly is not even near. You’re talking 197,000 miles vs. 37,000 miles. That’s 160,000 fewer miles! Assume of it this way: If you have been sponsoring a lifestyle insurance policies plan with your personal dollars, would you generate one for a 90-12 months-previous or a 20-year-old?

So absolutely grab the 2008 Aspect with 37,000 miles even though you can. And you can either sell your 2003 Ingredient for $3,500 (even though with a slipping transmission, good luck), or you can continue to keep it as a areas motor vehicle. Retaining it as a pieces motor vehicle has a couple of positive aspects. You may continue to be in a position to sit in it, breathe in the previous motor vehicle smell and reminisce. And you can consider your time transferring over all the aged canine hair.

Ray Magliozzi dispenses suggestions about cars and trucks in Motor vehicle Converse every single Saturday. E-mail him by browsing